How to make a unicorn pencil topper

Published on April 24, 2019

Skill level
Beginner Plus
Project time
3 hours

Writing will never be the same again once you’ve made a set of Christine Leech's unicorn head and butt pencil toppers. We're constantly making our pencils prance and mane toss across the page!


You will also need to print out the unicorn templates.

Download The Template

How to make the unicorn head

Making the mane


Take the rainbow yarn and the gold yarn and create a skein about 30cm long and 20 rounds.

Take several short pieces of embroidery thread and tie them at 10cm intervals along the skein.


Cut the yarn between the thread tie to create four or five small bundles.

Fold each bundle in half at the thread to make a bulkier bundle.


Using the template, cut out 2 unicorn heads in the white felt.


Place the two heads together and using a running stitch begin sewing up the neck of the unicorn from point A (but just a couple of stitches).

Then separate the two heads and insert the first bundle of mane between the two layers, put the heads together again and sew the bundle in place.


Repeat with the other bundles until you have filled the whole neck up to the top of the head.

Place the final bundle so half is on the neck and the other half goes over the top of the head (between where the ears will go) to create a fore lock.

Assembling the head


Using the templates cut two outer ear and two inner ear pieces. Use a little bit of fabric glue to stick the inner and outer ear pieces together.

Take one ear, pinch in half at the base of the ear and sew in place on one side of the Unicorn’s head. Repeat with the other ear. Make sure the forelock is still poking out between the ears.


Use the template to cut the Unicorn’s horn from the glitter felt. Fold in half and stitch together.

Cut the Q-tip down to the length of the horn and insert into the felt.

Place the horn between the two head pieces, close to the ears, and sew in place.

Pro Tip

If you do not have glitter felt then make the horn from yellow felt instead and then decorate with glitter at the end.


Continue sewing around the head until you come to point B, then insert the toy stuffing into the head.

Don’t fill too much but just enough to give it some shape.


Insert a pencil into the Unicorns head, wiggle it around a bit till you make a channel in the stuffing so the pencil sits comfortably and the head stays on.

Make it extra secure by sewing a running stitch through the head following the shape of the pencil.


To finish, sew an eye and some eyelashes on each side of the unicorn's head.

You can also add a little rosy cheek using a Q-tip dipped in a little blusher and rubbed onto the felt!

How to make the unicorn butt


Make a tail by winding the rainbow yarn and the gold yarn together around the palm of your hand about 20 times to create a mini skein.

Remove from your hand and tie a short piece of embroidery thread about 1cm down from one end of the skein. Snip through the other end.


Use the template to cut two heart shaped butt pieces.

Begin sewing the two pieces of butt together starting at point A. When you reach the peak of the heart shape open the two pieces and insert the tied end of the tail.

Close the butt and sew through the tail a couple of times to secure the tail in place.


Continue sewing together till you reach point B.

Insert a pencil into the unicorns butt (ha ha!), wiggle it around a bit till you make a channel in the stuffing so the pencil sits comfortably.

Make it extra secure by sewing a running stitch following the shape of the pencil.


Decorate with some sequins or small beads.

The only thing left to do is to go on a shopping trip for some cute new stationery to match your magical unicorns!

Discover More Free Tutorials

Celebrate the joy of creating! Share your craft and knowledge or pick up some tips.

Visit our international sites: Worldwide | Germany | Australia