Your selection may affect price, shipping options and product availability.

Suggested countries


All countries

The Most-Reviewed Yarns of August 2026
Articles (US) | September 09, 2026

The Most-Reviewed Yarns of August 2026

Reviewed by makers like you

5 yarns · 7 min read

Every month, makers share thousands of reviews with us—and like clockwork, a few standout yarns rise straight to the top. Not because we highlighted them, but because they’re the exact skeins you loved knitting and crocheting with all through August! Here are the five yarns you wrote about most, along with your real-world feedback—and every single one is in stock today.   

The short version

  • Paintbox Yarns Simply DK — August's absolute most-reviewed yarn—and the fan favorite makers routinely scoop up five shades at a time! 
  • Paintbox Yarns Cotton DK — The ultimate cotton yarn for amigurumi and summer bag patterns.
  • Paintbox Yarns Simply Aran — Delivers maximum coverage and quick results for large-scale knit and crochet projects.   
  • James C. Brett Super Soft Baby DK — Our community’s absolute go-to favourite for making handmade newborn gifts!
  • Paintbox Yarns Simply Chunky — Stitches up remarkably fast on large needles or hooks, turning your sweater goals into instant, wearable comfort.   

The Most-Reviewed Yarns of August 2026

Most reviewed this month
Paintbox Yarns Simply DK

Paintbox Yarns Simply DK

100% acrylic, DK weight

★★★★★

The single most-reviewed yarn in our shop this August—and the feedback is strikingly consistent! Makers love its sprawling colour palette, snag-free stitching that won't split on your hook or needles, and a budget-friendly price point that makes casting on a full-size blanket a completely reasonable idea.   

Shop Simply DK

Featured customer reviews

Verified review
★★★★★Aug 18, 2026

Paintbox Yarns Simply DK is my favorite "mitten yarn'! I knit lots of mittens! Mittens are always in progress around my other projects. If I have just a few minutes I can pick them up and have a little calm moment. This DK yarn comes in so many "kid friendly" colors! It"s consistent in texture, color, length of skeins, ease of use. The only "problem" I have ever encountered is that sometimes colors are unavailable. Even that doesn't last long! My patterns are decades old, as I am, and still no difficulties!

— Mary Lewis

Verified review
★★★★★Aug 17, 2026

I love paintbox yarn it is always my first go to and there are so many colours to choose from, I would fully recommend.

— Lesley Foxall

Verified review
★★★★★Aug 22, 2026

My order shipped quickly. and arrived accurately, which is always important for a project. I loved it so much I bought a bit more since the price was on point! I will definitely be using this yarn and your company again

— Ron zabriskie

Best for amigurumi
Paintbox Yarns Cotton DK

Paintbox Yarns Cotton DK

100% cotton, DK weight

★★★★★

August's top-rated cotton story! Makers reach for this favorite whenever crisp stitch definition is a must—for amigurumi toys, structured totes, and anything that needs to hold its shape—and they consistently note how much softer it feels than traditional cottons.   

Shop Cotton DK

Featured customer reviews

Verified review
★★★★★Aug 20, 2026

“Perfect feel and quality!”

Love this yarn! I can’t speak highly enough. It’s softer than other cottons I’ve tried.

— Lisa Bateman

Verified review
★★★★★Aug 14, 2026

“Dk cotton yarn”

I purchased the dk cotton yarn and have found it good to work with with no knots or frays as you go down the ball of the yarn. Competitively priced and a choice of colours it's perfect.

— Sandra Walker

Verified review
★★★★★Aug 11, 2026

I’ve used Paintbox for many years. I lave the skin tone colors for making. Knitted Knockers. The stitch definition is awesome. I’ve tried other yarns but keep returning to PAINTBOX!! Delivery time was exceptional and well packaged.

— Jackie Jackson

Best value pack
Paintbox Yarns Simply Aran

Paintbox Yarns Simply Aran

100% acrylic, aran weight

★★★★★

Step up from DK to achieve faster project completion. Reviewers frequently order ten-ball packs for full-sized blankets finished within a fortnight, rating its quality favourably against traditional shop-bought yarns.   

Shop Simply Aran

Featured customer reviews

Verified review
★★★★★Aug 9, 2026

I have made baby blankets and afghans and they are so soft and easy to work with.

— Linda Haworth

Verified review
★★★★★Aug 17, 2026

I always bought Aran wool from Shaws the Drapers, I’ve found Paintbox Aran to be the best quality to Shaws

— sharon Davies

Verified review
★★★★★Aug 7, 2026

“First class”

I love this wool. I have already had 5 full packs of 10 and will certainly purchase more when I need them. Very good value for money.

— Norah Weeden

Best for newborn gifts
James C. Brett Super Soft Baby DK

James C. Brett Super Soft Baby DK

100% acrylic, DK weight

★★★★★

The beloved baby yarn that featured again and again in August, usually recommended by makers on their third or fourth blanket! Soft enough for a newborn's delicate skin, fully machine washable, and wound into generous balls so you have far fewer ends to sew in.   

Shop Super Soft Baby DK

Featured customer reviews

Verified review
★★★★★Jun 30, 2026

“Good fast service, well packaged”

I have ordered this yarn several times to make baby blankets. It’s very soft, nice to work with and good value for money. I would go for this yarn every time

— Kathie Winters

Verified review
★★★★★May 11, 2026

“Great service”

This is such soft wool,so lovely to knit with & great choice of colours to choose from James Brett woo is always such good quality

— valerie seatherton

Verified review
★★★★★Apr 17, 2026

“Great yarn and great service”

Good price and quality. No flaws or splitting. Larger ball so less waste and less joining in and sewing in ends. Lovely colour, as shown.

— Joan Smith

Best for fast projects
Paintbox Yarns Simply Chunky

Paintbox Yarns Simply Chunky

100% acrylic, chunky weight

★★★★★

August’s top-rated choice for fast project completion. Cardigans, jumpers, and baby jackets lead customer reviews, with high repeat-purchase rates for secondary colour runs of favourite patterns.   

Shop Simply Chunky

Featured customer reviews

Verified review
★★★★★Jul 30, 2026

“Excellent yarn and service.”

Already made a cardigan in vanilla, it turned out so nice decided to knit one in blue. Lovely yarn to knit with.

— Susan Johnson

Verified review
★★★★★Jul 3, 2026

Lovely colours great price & knits up beautifully. Would recommend for all garments. Parcel arrived promptly & well packaged, many thanks for great products & excellent Customer Service.

— Margaret Donaldson

Verified review
★★★★★Jul 10, 2026

“Great for baby blankets”

I have used this yarn a number of times for baby blankets. The yarn is very soft and easy to work with.

— Louise Brown

How These Five Compare

Yarn Weight Best for
Paintbox Yarns Simply DK DK Everything: blankets, toys, baby knits, mittens
Paintbox Yarns Cotton DK DK Amigurumi, bags, summer tops, market bags
Paintbox Yarns Simply Aran Aran Blankets, afghans, toys, garments that grow fast
James C. Brett Super Soft Baby DK DK Baby blankets, matinee coats, christening knits
Paintbox Yarns Simply Chunky Chunky Cardigans, jumpers, blankets on big needles

What August Reviews Told Us

  • Acrylic is having a moment. Four of the five featured yarns are acrylics or acrylic blends—wonderfully washable, budget-friendly, and oh-so-soft against the skin! Perfect for everyday projects that need to combine plush comfort with hassle-free care.   
  • Colour range drives the purchase. The single most repeated feedback across our August reviews? Some variation of 'so many gorgeous colours to choose from!' Makers love having such a rich palette at their fingertips when planning their next knit or crochet project.   
  • Blankets rule the summer. Crafters didn't wait for the weather to turn before diving into cosy season. Reviews were filled with long-term blanket builds—from delicate baby blankets to year-long temperature trackers and plush sofa afghans—as makers prepped their homes for cooler days ahead.   
  • Christmas knitting has already started. It will come as no surprise that makers are already stitching for the Christmas season, but early gift prep was mentioned constantly across this month's reviews. Kudos to our organised community for planning so far ahead!

A tip from the LoveCrafts team: Swapping in one of these yarns for a pattern? Be sure to match the yarn weight and metres per ball above all else—those two figures dictate whether your pattern will fit properly. Remember that changing fibre content alters how your finished piece drapes and washes, so do knit a swatch and wash it exactly how you plan to care for the final garment!

Frequently Asked Questions

How is this list decided?

By review volume for the calendar month. We take every published review dated in August 2026, group it by yarn and rank the results. Anything out of stock when we publish comes off the list so you're not clicking through to an empty page.

Are these the best yarns you sell, or just the most reviewed?

The most reviewed — which usually means the most bought. Popularity and quality overlap here, but a specialist yarn with a small, devoted following will never top a list like this.

Is acrylic yarn worth using?

For anything that gets washed hard — baby blankets, children's jumpers, charity knitting — modern acrylic is hard to beat. Reviewers on this list consistently report it softening rather than pilling after repeated washes.

Which of these is best for a first project?

A DK weight acrylic. It shows your stitches clearly, forgives an uneven tension and costs little enough that a practice piece doesn't sting.

Do you restock colours that sell out?

The core shades of these ranges are restocked continuously. Seasonal and limited shades aren't always repeated, so if a project needs a specific one, buy the full quantity at once.

Will there be a list next month?

Yes — we publish a new one every month, built from that month's reviews.

by LoveCrafts
Check Out This Month's Hottest Blog Posts!

Added to your cart!

Your Cart Is Empty

Start Shopping